The Bold Pairing of a Tomahawk Steak and Cowboy Butter

The tomahawk is a steak that refuses to be ordinary. Cut from the rib primal, it carries the marbling of a ribeye with a long, frenched bone left intact, giving it a presence as striking as its flavour. More than just a cut of beef, it delivers a smoky crust that snaps, accompanied by a buttery interior that melts on the tongue.

That boldness finds its match in cowboy butter. Born from open-flame cooking traditions, this compound butter was crafted to complement hearty cuts eaten outdoors; its garlic, herbs, citrus, and spices cut through the smoke and char. Each spoonful melts over the steak, infusing the meat with layered, savoury notes that heighten every bite.

Yet bringing the two together is no casual act. The tomahawk must sear to a crisp without bitterness, rest long enough to hold its juices, and meet the butter at the precise moment when heat and fat are in perfect alignment. Done well, each bite delivers a smoky crust giving way to a tender, buttery interior layered with the spice and herb of the butter.

At a Glance:

• The tomahawk carries ribeye marbling on a long bone, delivering a smoky crust with a tender, buttery interior.
• Cowboy butter blends garlic, herbs, citrus, and spice, melting into the steak to layer flavour with every bite.
• Searing and slow fat rendering of the tomahawk ensures the centre stays juicy while the crust snaps, creating textural contrast.
• Apply the butter as the steak rests, then carve thick slices and combine each mouthful with the butter for a complete experience.
• Pair bites with full-bodied reds, Pinot Noir, Champagne, sake, or neat Japanese whisky to match the richness and spice.
• At DOORS Dubai, the steak is seared, rested, and served with paired drinks, letting the flavours come through seamlessly.

Beyond the Bone and Into the Cut

The tomahawk demands a different approach than typical steaks. Its thickness and long bone can make the centre undercooked while the exterior over-charred if heat isn’t managed carefully.

Slow, even rendering of the marbling is essential to achieve a tender, juicy interior, while a proper sear creates a crust that adds texture and flavour. Getting this balance right sets the stage for techniques that work around the bone to bring out the steak’s full potential.

1. Cooking Around the Bone

The tomahawk's thickness demands patience. A hard sear over high heat builds the crust, while slower finishing ensures the centre warms evenly and stays tender. The bone guides heat inward, while the marbling renders steadily, basting the meat from within.

What reaches the diner is a contrast of textures: a smoky crust that snaps and a centre that yields with buttery softness. The tomahawk’s size, bone, and marbling create a different experience on the plate compared with a standard ribeye.

2. From Pan to Plate

Once off the heat, the tomahawk must rest so its juices settle into the grain rather than spill away. Carved across the fibres, each slice reveals marbling glistening through tender flesh.

Served thick, at top steakhouses like DOORS Dubai, the bite is both powerful and indulgent: a charred edge against a custard-like centre, with a flavour that lingers long after the fork is set down.

The tomahawk’s sear and rest set the stage, but it’s the addition of cowboy butter that transforms each bite into a richer, more layered experience.

Cowboy Butter Heat and Herb

Cowboy butter is a relatively recent creation, born in American ranch kitchens and popularised at backyard grills. It takes the idea of compound butter, a French staple of herbs folded into softened butter, and gives it a rustic, fiery spin.

Garlic, mustard, parsley, lemon, and chilli made sense for cowboys cooking over open flame: bold flavours that could cut through smoke and fat while still keeping the beef at centre stage.

1. Building the Flavours of Cowboy Butter

At its core, cowboy butter starts with softened butter beaten until airy. Crushed garlic gives depth, Dijon mustard brings tang, and fresh herbs like parsley, chives, and thyme add freshness.

Lemon zest and juice lift the heaviness, while chilli flakes or smoked paprika deliver heat. It’s rolled into a log, chilled until firm, then sliced into discs that melt perfectly over hot meat.

2. Savouring Tomahawk with Cowboy Butter

What should feel like balance can easily tip the wrong way. Too much butter hides the beef, too little leaves it flat, and poor timing turns melt into scorch. To make the most of the pairing, a few simple rules matter:

• Add a slice just as the steak rests, letting it melt into the seared crust.
• Carve the tomahawk into thick slices so every piece catches the butter’s gloss.
• Spoon a little extra onto the plate for dipping, but never overload the meat.
• Always eat steak and butter together in one bite; this way, richness and lift arrive at the exact moment.

With each bite enriched by cowboy butter, the flavours invite drinks that can match the steak’s richness and lift its layers.

Complementing the Tomahawk

Richness, spice, and layered umami linger on the tomahawk with cowboy butter, demanding a drink that sharpens the flavours and refreshes the palate. Each sip interacts with the meat, guiding the tasting experience toward balance and clarity. Drinks that perform this work best include:

• Full-bodied reds – Bordeaux or Barolo bind the fat and give structure to each mouthful.
• Lighter reds – Pinot Noir lets the beef’s natural umami shine while remaining gentle.
• Champagne – Crisp carbonation lifts the butter’s spice and clears the palate between bites.
• Sake – Mineral undertones echo the meat’s depth, enhancing subtle flavours.
• Japanese whisky – Neat, with smoke and warmth that frame the finish without overpowering.

Experiencing Tomahawk at Its Best

A perfectly cooked tomahawk with cowboy butter needs the right environment to bring out its full flavour and character. At the wrong venue, even the finest cut can lose its impact, with taste muted or quality compromised.

DOORS Dubai, on Level 4 of Fashion Avenue of the Dubai Mall, gets it right. Each steak is seared with precision, rested to perfection, and finished with cowboy butter that melts into the grain. Dining on the terrace adds another dimension, with the Dubai Fountain’s choreographed display providing a living backdrop to the meal.

Reserve a table to experience this harmony of flavour, technique, and view.

FAQs

1. What makes a tomahawk steak different from a regular ribeye?

‍The tomahawk keeps the ribeye on a long, frenched bone, giving it presence and slower, even cooking. Its marbling renders deeply, creating a crust that snaps and an interior that stays tender and juicy.

2. What is cowboy butter, and why is it paired with tomahawk steak?

‍Cowboy butter is a compound butter that combines garlic, herbs, citrus, and spices. It melts over the steak, layering bold, bright flavours that enhance the beef without masking it.

3. How should cowboy butter be applied to the steak?

‍Place a slice on the steak as it rests, letting it melt over the crust. Carve thick slices so each bite carries both butter and beef in perfect balance.

4. What drinks pair best with tomahawk and cowboy butter?

‍Full-bodied reds, Pinot Noir, Champagne, sake, or neat Japanese whisky all elevate the tasting experience. Each sip refreshes the palate while complementing the steak's richness.

5. Where is the best place to enjoy a tomahawk with cowboy butter in Dubai?

‍The tomahawk is best served at DOORS Dubai after careful searing and resting, accompanied by drinks chosen to match the flavours of the steak.

‍